Making Arendellian Pickled Herring takes resources, patience, and a low sense of smell, but it’s worth it for your friendship with Elsa. Here’s how you can make your own Arendellian Pickled Herring so that you’re ready for her What Home Feels Like quest line.

Dreamlight Valley Arendellian Pickled Herring Recipe

Arendellian Pickled Herring requires the following ingredients:

  • One Herring
  • One Lemon
  • One Onion
  • One Garlic
  • One Herb

Thankfully, unlike the fish pie needed for the quest, this herring doesn’t need to glitter. You can catch these fish in both Dazzle Beach and the Glade of Trust. Lemons can be picked from trees in the Glade of Trust and the Forest of Valor.

Most of the other ingredients can be found in the Forest of Valor. You’ll find wild garlic growing in the ground and you can buy onions from Goofy’s Stall once you repair it. The last of the ingredients is either basil or oregano, depending on which one you feel like adding to the recipe.

Head to a stove and pop all of the ingredients into the pot along with a piece of coal. The resulting product will be five-star Arendellian Pickled Herring. We’ll never know how pickled herring could have more stars than cherry pie, but Elsa sure seems to be a fan. Give her the herring as part of the quest line to jog her memory about secrets buried in the Ice Cavern.

Looking for more Disney Dreamlight Valley content on GameTips.PRO? Check out How to make Sautéed Mushrooms in Disney Dreamlight Valley (and other mushroom dishes).

Leave a comment